Archive by Month: February 2018

Indemnitors: Not A Surety’s Sureties

By David A. Harris February 21, 2018 Articles

When a surety sues to enforce its indemnity agreement, it is not uncommon for the indemnitors to argue they are the surety’s “sureties” and so entitled to all the same legal protections of a surety.

On its face, the argument might seem plausible. After all, according to Black’s Law Dictionary, a surety is “[s]omeone who is primarily liable for paying another's debt or performing another's obligation.” And aren’t the indemnitors being asked by the surety to pay for the principal’s debt? Or so the argument goes.  

A recent Georgia Court of Appeals case shot down this argument. Zambetti v. Cheeley Investments, L.P., 343 Ga. App. 637, 808 S.E.2d 41 (2017). The plaintiff sued to enforce the defendant’s oral agreement to pay the plaintiff’s attorneys’ fees. The defendant argued the statute of frauds precluded the enforcement of his oral agreement. The court held that the statute of frauds did not apply and distinguished a contract of indemnity from a guaranty.  

A guaranty or surety relationship is created when “one party promise[s] the original creditor that he would pay the debt of the original debtor if that debtor fail[s] to pay.” This is contrasted with a contract for indemnity, where “the indemnitor, for a consideration, promises to indemnify and save harmless the indemnitee against liability of the indemnitee to a third person, or against loss resulting from such liability.” Id.  

The key difference between the two relationships is that the surety’s obligation is to the original obligee. The indemnitors’ obligations are to reimburse the surety. Under Georgia law, this distinction determines whether or not the statute of frauds and other protections enjoyed by the surety apply.  

Read More

Bovis, Kyle, Burch & Medlin Attorneys Named to the 2018 Georgia Super Lawyers Lists

By February 19, 2018 News/Events/Seminars

We are pleased to announce that fourteen attorneys at Bovis, Kyle, Burch & Medlin, LLC have been selected to the 2018 Georgia Super Lawyers lists. These are exclusive lists, recognizing a small percentage of attorneys in the state.

Kim M. Jackson was named to Georgia’s Top 100 list. Attorneys on the top list have been selected to the 2018 Georgia Super Lawyers list and ranked top of the list in the Super Lawyers selection Process.



Read More